Missing: 16-Year-Old Kimberly Arrington Vanishes In 1998 After Visiting CVS Pharmacy

Back when I was a kid, I used to spend summers visiting my grandparents in the Midwest. I returned to the home that my mother was raised in for family time as my relatives, dozens of them, would stop by almost every day to eat, lounge, and just spend time with one another. My cousins and I played in the streets with the neighborhood kids and often we would ask permission to walk to the market around the corner to get candy, snacks, or my favorite, Faygo pop.

The latter is something that is common for children all around the country. They leave their home only to take a short walk to visit friends or take a quick trip to the store. It’s expected that kids won’t take long when they’re away and they’ll return safe and sound.

That wasn’t the case for 16-year-old Kimberly Nicole Arrington.


The day before Halloween in 1998 in Montogomery, Alabama, Kimberly left her home to go to her neighborhood CVS Pharmacy to buy candy and a soda around 4:00 p.m. in the evening. When she didn’t return within the hour, her parents were unnerved. They went to the store to look for her themselves and were told that yes, Kimberly did make it to the CVS, but no one saw her after that. They contacted the police after they personally searched for her for hours with no leads as to her whereabouts and reported her missing.

Although there was no evidence that Kimberly was a runaway, police treated her as such because of her age. The Jefferson Davis High School tenth-grader was described as being a happy teen who didn’t have a rebellious streak. She liked music and dancing as well as computers. Kimberly was getting her Christmas shopping plans together with family and was scheduling a time with her father to buy items for her loved ones. Nothing indicated that Kimberly left her home distraught.

Detectives may have initially believed that Kimberly ran away from home, but now they suspect that she, at some point during her visit to the CVS store, was abducted. She was last seen at CVS, however, there are no witnesses who saw her in distress and there isn’t any evidence to show that she was involved in a situation that endangered her life.

When Kimberly Arrington disappeared she was last seen wearing:

  • Gray Bugle Boy shirt with a collar
  • Light blur Levi’s jeans
  • White Reebok sneakers (gray trim)
  • Emerald ring with two diamonds on each side
  • Double heart ring set with a diamond

She is described as having a small surgical scar on the left side of her abdomen and both of her ears are pierced. It should also be noted that Kimberly suffers from allergies that are said to be severe. At the time of her disappearance, she was spending the majority of her time inside as to avoid flare-ups and irritations.

The lead photo at the top of this page: (left) what Kimberly looked like when she was last seen, (right) computerized age progression of what she may look like as an adult.

In 2005, Kimberly’s mother passed away without knowing what happened to her daughter. The missing teen’s father, however, is still living and he continues to search for his daughter.

Please share this article to continue the discussion about Kimberly. She is not forgotten.

If you have any information regarding Kimberly Nicole Arrington’s disappearance that occurred 20 years ago, please contact Montgomery Police Department 334-241-2790.